Round 5: Tournament Vote Off (19th Day) --- NFL QB's ---- Up now --- E. MANNING vs B. FARVE --- Pick the Winner

This is a simple tournament style vote off. What you do here is vote for the best QB of the pair that is up at that time. This is a tournament so vote for the top paring first the next match up will begin after 15 total votes, the first to 8 votes, or the leader at the 24th hour, whichever comes first.

Then move to the next pairing on the list and so on till the list is complete and then we start round two which I will post with the new match ups. I will Post the new match ups every day till we crown the CHAMPION.

Lets be friendly and honest here is the match up. The NAMES in CAPS are the winners of that match up move on to the next round. When you see a pairing with a CAPS winner move down to where there are two QB's in lower case letters and that is the one we will be voting on at that time. When the next round comes out it will be posted the same as this one but with round 2, then 3, then 4 and so on till we have our two SUPER BOWL QB's. Only vote for the one in session.

Let's keep it friendly, and tell your friends we are here and lets make this fun for everyone.

NOW IN SESSION IS: --- E. MANNING vs B. FARVE

E. MANNING vs B. FARVE --- NOW IN SESSION

D. MCNABB --- BYE (had the best score of 10-6 last round)

60 Comments On: "Round 5: Tournament Vote Off (19th Day) --- NFL QB's ---- Up now --- E. MANNING vs B. FARVE --- Pick the Winner"

 
hmmm

WTF was he thinking when he put that outfit on??? Paris looks good though.

second those statements DaBirds, LOL


favre. this is a joke

morning jackson, BF it is


Brett farve... All though Eli has looked vrey good this preaseason

Morning REDS, BF it is


My vote is for

B. Favre

Current Score is:

B. Favre over E. Manning --- 3 - 0

Brett Favre he's got history and he's a better QB currently as well.

Morning 5forlife, BF it is

Morning, well I guess Afternoon now The Dean1.

Dean rate my fantasy team tell me what you think... well everyone rate it let me know what you think...
I picked 6 th tom brady
frank gore
ryan grant
jason witten.... ugh cowboy
brandon marshall
lee evans
donald driver
marc bulger
selvin young- travis henry is cut
vernon davis.... gta love mike martz
patrick crayton- should be a decent wr with the absence of t glenn
giants d... Bad pick it seems like...
duce mcallister-why was he still around
pitts d
giants kicker dumb pick the guy might be out for the year but its a kicker...
and the jets kicker...once again its a kicker

I think you took Tom Brady too early... as is your RB's were hurt big time for it. I hate Frank Gore always have always will. The guy just doesn't get enough TD's. Not sold on Ryan Grant just yet, could be a nice pick up tho. As much as I hate to say it Witten is like having a number 1 WR on your team if he does what he did last year. I don't know how many WR's you start, but if it's three you are lacking depth behind them. I am not high up on Lee Evans either. Just my opinion. Overall I don't believe it's a horrible team but you have some work to do. How many teams are there if there are 12 I would def say it's a better draft! Here's mine Let me know what you think.
Start 1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 1K 1DEF 10 Team league
DrewBrees
Joseph Addai
DarrenMcFadden
Larry Fitz
Torry Holt
Calvin Johnson
Chris Cooley
No Kicker yet
Jacksonville D
Bench: Greg Jennings Matt Forte, Ronnie Brown, DeAngeloWilliams, Mark Bulger, Vincent Jackson, SidneyRice, Chris Perry, Desean Jackson.
I am Def weak at my 2nd starting RB which I am trying to work a trade to improve. Let me know what you think.

Dabirds, strong team, can you let on as to the k ur looking at?

REDS, help me out here>>>

What type of league and how many teams? (is it a reg league or keeper, 8, 10, 12, 14 teams)
How are the players played ( example: 1 qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1k, 1def/st)
Basic scoring system or something different?

I ask cause 1 of mine is a 8 team, I picked 2nd, basic scoring, 1qb, 2 rb, 3wr, 1te, 1def/st, 1 linemen, 1 lb, 1 db) for 11 guys and we pick 5 bench guys.

As for the giants K, i hear they cut him 1 day after signing him so which one did you pick?
A good D vs Giants if you still can is Buffalo....as for duce, his knee is still iffy, grant maybe a tough pick till we see what the qb does and if the D's blitz, 7 or 8 man fronts/in the box making it tougher to run. I like the pick though, how many backs do you play a week? 1, 2, or 3? from the looks of it you play 2 bench 1, is that right? play 1 def and sit 1, do you get that teams ST too? If so Buffalo would be a good pick, I look for their DEF and ST to do well this season since their schedule is weaker than normal and they will fight it out for the WC with the NYJ. I like your TE's. If Buffalo has the help they drafted for at WR then Lee will be a good pick, of your starters, Driver is where my question marks come depending on if the line gives qb time or not, I do like the Crayton pick. Does this help?

Current Score is:

B. Favre over E. Manning --- 4 - 0

Farve... You can move on to the next voting... lol

Current Score is:

B. Favre over E. Manning --- 5 - 0

dabirds check ths link.... its called, "Why do you play Fantasy Football?"

http://www.yardbarker.com/nfl/articles/Why_do_you_play_Fantasy_Football/312353

Sorry to turn this into a Fantasy Football page Dean, but you and I both know whos going to win this poll. LOL

Dabirds this is all good, The fantasy football is great it was one we were going to put up friday, however, today is good too. You have a strong looking team, ideas on your K yet?

Yea its funny d mac is going to win... He has no superbowl rings... Also I don't think he has ever even been M.V.P..LOL... I know I voted against Manning for Dmac I don't care how many thumbs down I get for this one... But let me ask you this If were to ather take a qb in a draft or start from scratch and had first pick on Qb it would not be mcnabb... Mcnabb is probably the 4th or 5 th best Qb in football... Sorry...

I'm with you REDS, I voted brees and P. manning over D. Mac. I love the guy and his play when healthy and on and on, but I said in national polls and FF Drafts he goes between 6th and 12th.

check this link.... its called, "Why do you play Fantasy Football?"

http://www.yardbarker.com/nfl/articles/Why_do_you_play_Fantasy_Football/312353

Dean we are a ten team league 1 qb,2rbs,2wrs,1t.e,1k,1d...
Duce is a number 4...Buffalo is gone... I have tynes for the Giants he isn't cut...But he just had surgery... The Kicker that was cut was from k.c... I had my picks narrowed down at 6 had to take Brady... Then some how landed gore with the 14th... then Landed Grant with the 26th...

are a position person or best player person when you draft?

I like the team... who do you guys have left to pick and choose from? or don't you guys do that?

I ask cause I just had a guy offer me matt ryan for cotchery... I countered with,

Cotchery, white and turner for matt ryan, willis, forte..... And the guy took it, LOL.....

Yea In my league it wen't brady,romo,manning...
then palmer dumb pick, then brees then Dmac he wen't 6th... D mac doesn't have the legs any more... and doesn't have the recieving core to be in the same sentence as manning or brady..Brady played with deion Branch for how long... and deion branch was a no body... and still is no 1000 wr years 0... he won 3 superbowls with that garbage on his team ... pure garbage... and manning... well he is just perfect... The guy reads deffences as good as the Eagles Blitz.

I disagree McNabb's legs are much better than last year and he had 350 yards rushing it can only be better two years removed from the ACL tear.

There not like they used to be though...Mcnabb was a fast running force... I loved seeing him run...Mcnabb has put on alot of legs... and he is a completely different qb then he was in 04... I will say this though there are 3 or 4 qbs I ould be afraid to tackle..Dmac..The guy is Huge,Culpepper another one huge,jamarcus russel he's a monster///

REDS and DaBirds, here is one of my teams in one of my leagues. Analyze and rip it apart and give me your feedbacks, or anyone for that matter.

8 team, I picked 2nd, basic scoring, 1qb, 2 rb, 3wr, 1te, 1def/st, 1 linemen, 1 lb, 1 db) for 11 guys and we pick 5 bench guys and for Def guys we play 1 bench 1, so our totals are 11offensive guys, 5 bench, 3 individual def players and 3 bench for 22 total players.

I picked 2nd...

LT RB
R. Moss WR
M. Lynch RB
M. Turner RB
A. Johnson WR
A. Gates TE
D. Brees QB
W. Welker WR
B. Favre QB
D. Clark TE
TB Def/St
A. Kampmal DL
Buffalo Def/St
P. Posluszny LB
Cotchery WR
K. Rhodes DB
L. White RB
D. Ware LB
E. Dumervil DL
A. Cromartie DB
Rackers K
Lindell K

Go for it, let me know what you think...

Sorry man would have commented sooner but was our for lunch... I am just trying to figure out who you picked with the 2nd pick? Had to be Moss I would presume. I would have not taken him at 2 thats for sure, but maybe your scoring is geared towards WR's. I don't know. Solid QB (same as mine lol) I like Lynch, Turner scares me a bit since he is in Atlanta. Sweet WR's in Moss and Johnson and a solid bye week sub in Welker. Great TE in Gates. Some good back up in there. I think I would pick a different LB who is going to gobble up the tackles over PUZ ( GO STATE ). I think if I were you I would package up Turner and White or Welker and try to land yourself a stud at your 2nd RB. I know easier said than done. Not too bad all around though just a bit weak at that 2nd RB (just like me)

DaBirds, I'm ROFL, LOL...
I just had a guy offer me matt ryan for cotchery... I countered with,

Cotchery, white and turner for matt ryan, willis, forte..... And the guy took it, LOL.....

UPDATED got a trade over and I countered and he took it

My updated team is now as follows:

I picked 2nd...

LT RB
R. Moss WR
M. Lynch RB
M. Turner RB
A. Johnson WR
A. Gates TE
D. Brees QB
W. Welker WR
B. Favre QB
D. Clark TE
TB Def/St
A. Kampmal DL
Buffalo Def/St
P. Posluszny LB
Cotchery WR
K. Rhodes DB
L. White RB
D. Ware LB
E. Dumervil DL
A. Cromartie DB
Rackers K
Lindell K

Go for it, let me know what you think...

LT RB
R. Moss WR
M. Lynch RB
M. Turner RB
A. Johnson WR
A. Gates TE
D. Brees QB
W. Welker WR
B. Favre QB
D. Clark TE
TB Def/St
A. Kampmal DL
Buffalo Def/St
P. Posluszny LB
Cotchery WR
K. Rhodes DB
L. White RB
D. Ware LB
E. Dumervil DL
A. Cromartie DB
Rackers K
Lindell K

I just had a guy offer me matt ryan for cotchery... I countered with,

Cotchery, white and turner for matt ryan, willis, forte..... And the guy took it, LOL.....

Yeah I see your point but at ;east they're not like last year.

your teams good dean...the welker moss... Is so solid.... and so smart...
you own new englans wr game..!!! Great Move on that...Your Rbs are really a weak spot... Turner.. Is decent but remember he was running behind Lt's Line... and getting Lt's scraps!!Now he has Atlanta ... Atlanta is just bad... Pieriod.. other then your rb's your solid...But one thing I will say having Dallas Clark and gates, as well as having farve and brees..Might land you a rb... You can always use your back ups as bait..

Kudos for reiterating my sentiments... lol

why do you guys feel my backs are weak? Since that trade with Jason23 my backs are

LT RB
M. Lynch RB
Forte RB --- Got off a trade

thompsonphilly and I have a trade going now...

My offer is Matt Ryan, & D. Ware for Reggie Wayne and a 4th RB (Sproles from SD) i was going to handcuff him to LT. What do you guys think?

If he bites, I have 2 guys looking for kickers and /or I was going to offer sandman2314,

WOAH DUDE... I am totally blind!!! I didn't see LT at the top!?!?!?! Sorry work is taking its toll on me today! OK now I have another question how the **** did Moss find his way back to you when you were the 2nd pick??????? SOLID team. Keep workin those trades build up the depth. Cheers.

THis year the hype before the draft was RB's by commity and QB's are hurt so they loaded up on RB's and QB's. I was surprised Moss was there and even more shocked with all the RB's NO ONE took Lynch. As you can see I was 1st to take RB, Brady went 1st pick. I was the first to pick WR, TE.

Where I am the most surprised is the K's I got with my last 2 picks, LOL.....

Now I just need depth as you said.

How'd you like that willis trade baby at LB, I'd say I'm ok there wouldn't you?

LT RB
M. Lynch RB
Forte RB --- Got off a trade

QB's
D. Brees QB
B. Favre QB
matt ryan QB off trade

WR's
R. Moss WR
A. Johnson WR
W. Welker WR

TE's
A. Gates TE
D. Clark TE

Def/ST
TB Def/St
Buffalo Def/St

K's
Rackers K
Lindell K

DL
A. Kampmal DL
E. Dumervil DL

LB's
Willis --- off trade
P. Posluszny LB
D. Ware LB

DB's
K. Rhodes DB
A. Cromartie DB

sry for ruining the fantasy convo, but favre haa

your good gobirds, BF it is